> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://noahpression.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The roots of Him Hold Ye In Your Mind
- URL: https://noahpression.com/roots/the-roots-of-him-hold-ye/
- Published: 2026-10-28T14:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-28T14:00:00.000Z
- Description: Robin Hood's first orders, the Peasants' Revolt, and six centuries of fighting over who the outlaw belongs to.
- Author: Noah Pression
- Tags: Roots, #pair-him-hold-ye

### The short version

The oldest long Robin Hood poem, the *Gest of Robyn Hode*, was written in the 1400s. In it, Robin tells his men to harm no farmer at his plough, to beat and bind bishops and archbishops, and to keep the Sheriff of Nottingham in mind. Paul Buhle's *Robin Hood: People's Outlaw and Forest Hero* reads that list against its world: a forest the king had fenced off with savage laws, the great rising of 1381, and village crowds who called themselves Robin Hood's men when they went to take something back. Over six centuries the powerful tried to tame Robin into an earl. Radicals kept taking him back, from a French Revolution sympathizer in 1795 to blacklisted Hollywood writers in the 1950s. Scholars still argue about how radical the first Robin was. The argument is the point: everyone wants Robin on their side.

### The story

**Lythe and listin.** The *Gest* (say "jest"; it means a tale of deeds) was probably composed between about 1450 and 1475, out of older stories. It was among the first English poems printed, around 1500, in London and in Antwerp. A copy of the Antwerp edition in the National Library of Scotland has a woodcut on its title page that is the oldest known picture of Robin Hood. The poem is 456 four-line verses long. The song uses verses 1 to 3 and 11 to 15: the introduction, and Robin's rules of the road.

It begins by calling its audience "gentilmen... of frebore blode": free men, not serfs. Robin is a "yeman," a yeoman, a free commoner who is neither lord nor serf. He doesn't live in Sherwood yet. He stands in Barnsdale, a wood beside the Great North Road in Yorkshire, perfect for stopping travelers.

**The rules.** Little John asks where they'll take and where they'll leave, where they'll rob and where they'll "reve" (plunder), and who they'll "bete and bynde." Robin's answer, in verses 13 to 15, is a social map of medieval England:

- **Spare the "husbonde" who tills with his plough.** A husbonde was a small tenant farmer, one rank below the yeoman. The song says "peasant," which is a little broader than the original but true to its spirit.
- **Spare the good yeoman, and even the knight or squire who will be a "gode felawe."** Robin's war is not on everyone with land.
- **Beat and bind the bishops and archbishops.** In 1450 the Church was one of England's greatest landlords. Later in the *Gest* the villain is a rich abbot who holds a knight's land in pledge for a debt.
- **"The hye sherif of Notyingham, hym holde ye in your mynde."** The sheriff was the king's officer in the county: tax collector, jailer and police chief. Keep him in mind is an understatement. By the end of the poem Robin has killed him.

![Chart: Robin Hood's orders, from A Gest of Robyn Hode, stanzas 13 to 15. Spare: the peasant who tills with his plough, the good yeoman of the greenwood, the knight or squire who will be a good fellow. Beat and bind: the bishops and the archbishops. Hold in mind: the High Sheriff of Nottingham. Each column quotes the original Middle English.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/2c/60/2c609e39-7bc2-4daa-bb27-780b5e9b4baf/content/images/2026/10/02-who-robin-robs.png)

Robin Hood's orders: *A Gest of Robyn Hode*, stanzas 13 to 15.

**Robin before the *Gest*.** The name turns up in court records long before the poem. In 1225–26 a "Robert Hod, fugitive" is listed in Yorkshire. By the late 1200s "Robehod" was a nickname clerks gave to outlaws. Around 1377, in *Piers Plowman*, a lazy priest admits he can't say the Lord's Prayer properly but knows the "rymes of Robyn Hood." Robin was the people's entertainment before he was anyone's literature.

**The king's forest.** Buhle begins where the ballads begin, in the forest (pp. 15–17). Before the Normans, much English woodland was worked as a commons: villagers grazed animals there, cut wood for tools and houses, and shared those rights by custom. After 1066 the new kings declared huge stretches of country "forest," a legal category more than a landscape, and kept the deer for themselves. Killing one could cost a man his life, and Buhle notes that courts were often gentler with a pickpocket than with a deer poacher. Barons forced some of that land back out of royal hands in Magna Carta (1215) and the Charter of the Forest (1217), but the forest stayed the king's. It was also where England's best archers came from: Buhle points out that many of the longbowmen who won battles in France were recruited from the king's so-called poachers (p. 39). An outlaw with a bow in the king's wood wasn't a fantasy. He was a neighbor.

**1381.** Four years after *Piers Plowman*, England had its first great popular uprising. The Black Death had killed perhaps a third of the country. Workers who survived could bargain for better pay, so Parliament froze wages and forbade laborers to move; then the government added a poll tax on every adult. In June 1381 crowds that Buhle puts as high as a hundred thousand marched on London (pp. 40–43). They burned the palace of the king's uncle, John of Gaunt, and by common agreement destroyed the valuables they found instead of stealing them. At Smithfield their leader, Wat Tyler, asked the fourteen-year-old Richard II for an end to serfdom and outlawry, no lordship but the king's, and the Church's wealth shared among the people. During that meeting the Mayor of London struck him down. A radical priest, John Ball, had preached to the rebels at Blackheath: "When Adam delved and Eve span, who was then the gentleman?" The rising was crushed and Ball was hanged, drawn and quartered. Buhle sees Robin's popularity growing out of this world, and notes that many rebels had come home from the French wars with their own bows (p. 38). Others, notably J. C. Holt, point out that the ballads never mention serfdom, rents or wages, the actual grievances of 1381\. Both are right, in a way: the *Gest* is not a manifesto, but it knows exactly who it doesn't like.

**Robin Hood's men.** Through the 1400s and 1500s towns across Britain held Robin Hood games: May Day festivals where commoners chose a Robin, a Marian and a Friar Tuck, collected money and turned the world upside down for a day. Buhle shows how easily the game turned real (pp. 5, 58–59). In Norfolk in 1441, laborers and yeomen blocked a road, chanted that they were "Robynhodesmen," and threatened a local lord who had taken away a right they counted as theirs. At Wednesbury in Staffordshire in 1497, a man charged with leading a riot under Robin's name told the court it was only a play. Scotland's Parliament banned the games in 1555\. In 1561 Edinburgh's apprentices and craftsmen defied the ban: they elected a "Lord of Inobedience," pushed past the magistrates and marched up to the castle over their work and wages. The reformer John Knox fumed about the "rascal multitude."

![Timeline, six centuries of Robin Hood: 1225, "Robert Hod, fugitive" appears in a Yorkshire court record; c. 1377, in Piers Plowman a priest knows the rhymes of Robin Hood; June 1381, the Peasants' Revolt marches on London; 1441, Norfolk laborers block a road as "Robynhodesmen"; c. 1450 to 1510, A Gest of Robyn Hode is composed, then printed; 1561, Edinburgh craftsmen elect a "Lord of Inobedience"; 1795, Joseph Ritson takes Robin back for the people; 1955, blacklisted writers put Robin on television.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/2c/60/2c609e39-7bc2-4daa-bb27-780b5e9b4baf/content/images/2026/10/02-timeline.png)

Six centuries of Robin Hood: who the outlaw belonged to, and who kept trying to take him back.

**Taming Robin.** Then the gentry adopted him. In 1521 the Scottish historian John Major wrote that Robin robbed only the rich and never the poor. By the 1590s playwrights had made him a dispossessed nobleman, the Earl of Huntingdon, a rich man's son wronged by a bad prince. A rebel against the system became a victim of one bad king, waiting for the good one to come home.

**Taking him back.** In 1795 Joseph Ritson, a lawyer, vegetarian and open supporter of the French Revolution, published the first scholarly collection of the Robin Hood ballads. He called Robin a man who, "in a barbarous age, and under a complicated tyranny, displayed a spirit of freedom and independence which has endeared him to the common people... for all opposition to tyranny is the cause of the people." When an earlier writer asked who gave Robin the right to take from where it could best be spared and give to where it was most needed, Ritson answered: the same power "which authorises kings to take where it can be worst spared, and give it where it is least wanted." (Ritson still made Robin an earl.) In the 1800s, as enclosure fenced off England's common land, writers turned Robin's greenwood into the commons itself.

**Robin brings John Ball.** Ninety years after Ritson, the socialist designer William Morris wrote *A Dream of John Ball* (serialized in *Commonweal*, 1886–87), in which a time traveler lands among the rebels of 1381 and a ballad singer reminds him that he always said "Robin Hood should bring us John Ball." Buhle reads Morris as the clearest statement of why Robin matters to the left: the outlaw is the old dream of freedom that keeps calling up new rebels (pp. 12–19). His own book takes its cue from Ritson (p. 10).

**The blacklist.** In 1955 an American producer in London, Hannah Weinstein, launched *The Adventures of Robin Hood* on British and American television. Her writers included Ring Lardner Jr., one of the Hollywood Ten, who had served time in prison for refusing to name names, along with other blacklisted Americans, all writing under false names. Lardner later said the show gave them "plenty of opportunities to comment on issues and institutions in Eisenhower-era America." Every week, in the middle of the McCarthy era, millions of Americans watched an outlaw defy a sheriff who abused his power, written by people their own government had outlawed.

Buhle calls it perhaps the best Robin of all (pp. 69–72) and says it drew 32 million viewers on both sides of the Atlantic. The scripts smuggled the times in: Robin's band shields an old woman accused of witchcraft, works with a French underground, backs a "people's priest" against the sheriff, and frustrates the tax man week after week. The theme song's tag, "Feared by the bad, loved by the good," stayed with a generation that went on to the civil rights movement (p. 6).

**The fight over Robin.** He keeps being claimed. A billionaire can call him a tax protester; a stock-trading app can borrow his name. Historians still argue whether the first Robin was a peasant rebel, a yeoman's hero or a merchant's fantasy. The early ballads' Robin, the scholars Stephen Knight and Thomas Ohlgren note, robs the rich "but give\[s\] to themselves." The *Gest* itself ends by saying he "dyde pore men moch god": did poor men much good. That is the line people have fought over ever since.

**Green Robin.** Buhle ends with the forest again (pp. 78–98). Enclosure, the fencing of the old commons for sheep and profit a couple of centuries after the *Gest*, is in his telling exactly what Robin's band stood in the way of, and it never stopped: today's fights over privatized land, water and public space are the same fight. Robin's heirs turn up everywhere, from the Midnight Robber of Trinidad's Carnival, a storyteller in a skull-studded cape who recites the history of slavery and resistance, to Tom Sawyer playing Robin Hood in the woods behind his town. Wherever a commons is being taken, somebody picks up Robin's bow.

### What the song changes, and why

- **"Peasant."** The original is "husbonde," a small farmer who works his own rented land. "Husband" means something else now, so the song uses the closest modern word.
- **The repeats.** Little John's question comes twice and "beat and bind" echoes, the way a crowd would join in. The last line adds what a 21st-century crowd would add.
- **What's left out.** Verses 4 to 10, where Robin refuses to eat until a guest arrives and swears never to harm a company with a woman in it, are skipped. They're worth reading.

### What it connects to

- [**Two Guns**](https://noahpression.com/songs/two-guns/)**.** The *Gest* says keep the sheriff in mind. Sid Hatfield was a lawman who refused to be the sheriff, and the coal companies treated him the way Nottingham treats Robin. Buhle argues that the gunfighter hero of the Western is Robin with a six-gun instead of a bow (pp. 9, 58); Sid, the two-gun lawman of the coalfields, was that hero for real.
- **Night of the Johnstown Flood.** The *Gest*'s villain is a rich abbot who uses debt to take a knight's land. The Johnstown villains were a fishing club of millionaires who fenced off a mountain lake for themselves and left the valley below to carry the risk. Buhle's Robin is a defender of the commons. Same list, new names. \[Forthcoming in [Storytime EP](https://noahpression.bandcamp.com/album/storytime-ep?ref=noahpression.com)\]
- **I Hight Don Quixote.** Ritson read the old ballads as proof that "all opposition to tyranny is the cause of the people." Parsons said the same thing in 1946: you can't secure your own freedom without securing everyone's. \[Forthcoming in [Storytime EP](https://noahpression.bandcamp.com/album/storytime-ep?ref=noahpression.com)\]
- For more numbers-first work on empire and rebellion, see [Star Wars Death Math](https://deathmath.show/?ref=noahpression.com).

### Sources

1. Buhle, Paul. *Robin Hood: People's Outlaw and Forest Hero; A Graphic Guide*. Illustrated by Chris Hutchinson, Gary Dumm and Sharon Rudahl. Oakland: PM Press, 2011\. The main source for this song. Used here: the introduction (pp. 5–11), forest law and the commons (pp. 15–17), Morris and John Ball (pp. 12–19), 1381 and the longbow (pp. 37–47), the Robin Hood games and the *Gest* (pp. 57–60), Ritson (pp. 61–62), the 1950s TV series (pp. 69–72), Green Robin and the commons (pp. 78–98).
2. *A Gest of Robyn Hode* (Child 117A). In Francis James Child, *The English and Scottish Popular Ballads*, vol. 3, 1888\. Text: https://www.peterrobins.co.uk/ballads/items/117A
3. Knight, Stephen, and Thomas H. Ohlgren, eds. *Robin Hood and Other Outlaw Tales*. Kalamazoo: TEAMS Middle English Texts, 1997\. https://d.lib.rochester.edu/teams/text/gest-of-robyn-hode-introduction
4. Ritson, Joseph. *Robin Hood: A Collection of All the Ancient Poems, Songs, and Ballads*. London, 1795\. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/56926/56926-h/56926-h.htm
5. Morris, William. *A Dream of John Ball*. Serialized in *Commonweal*, 1886–87; published as a book in 1888.
6. Holt, J. C. *Robin Hood*. London: Thames and Hudson, 1982.
7. Knight, Stephen. "Robin Hood and the Forest Laws." *Bulletin of the International Association for Robin Hood Studies*. https://openjournals.bsu.edu/biarhs/article/download/2837/1693/
8. Coward, M. "The radical who invented Robin Hood." *Portside*, December 13, 2025 (first published in the *Morning Star*). https://portside.org/2025-12-13/radical-who-invented-robin-hood
9. Cox, J. "Reclaiming the radical legend of Robin Hood." *Socialist Worker* 3002, April 18, 2026\. https://socialistworker.co.uk/reviews-and-culture/reclaiming-the-radical-legend-of-robin-hood/
10. Taraghan, D. "Robin Hood, Ireland, and the communists." *Socialist Voice*, October 7, 2018\. https://socialistvoice.ie/2018/10/robin-hood-ireland-and-the-communists/
11. Wikipedia. "A Gest of Robyn Hode," "Peasants' Revolt," "John Ball (priest)," "Wat Tyler," "Charter of the Forest," "The Adventures of Robin Hood (TV series)," "Hannah Weinstein." Accessed October 2026.