Nobody knows much about Isaac G. Reed. His poem survives because it said, in two lines, what Johnstown's survivors already knew. The flood was not just bad weather. Fourteen miles upriver, the South Fork Dam held back a private lake for the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club, whose members included Andrew Carnegie, Henry Clay Frick and Andrew Mellon. The club had patched the old dam without an engineer, lowered its top, screened its spillway to keep the fish in, and never replaced the pipes that could have drained it. When it broke on May 31, 1889, it sent a wall of water through the valley and into a steel town of 30,000 working people.
Reed lists the dead (husbands, wives, daughters, sons, "hosts of martyred little ones"), calls it worse than Herod's massacre of the innocents, and then lands the blow: "All the horrors that hell could wish, / Such was the price that was paid for—fish!"
It needed a tune now because the arrangement hasn't changed: someone upstream decides what risk is acceptable, and someone downstream pays for it.
Lyrics
Many thousand human lives,
butchered husbands, slaughtered wives,
mangled daughters, bleeding sons,
hosts of martyred little ones,
worse than Herod's awful crime,
sent to heaven before their time.
Worse than Herod's awful crime,
sent to heaven before their time.
Many thousand human lives,
butchered husbands, slaughtered wives,
lovers burnt and sweethearts drowned,
darlings lost but never found,
worse than Herod's awful crime,
sent to heaven before their time.
Worse than Herod's awful crime,
sent to heaven before their time!
Many thousand human lives,
butchered husbands, slaughtered wives,
all the horrors that hell could wish,
such was the price paid for...
Fish! Fish!
For the rich! For the rich!
2,209!
Two thousand two hundred nine lives,
two thousand two hundred nine lives
were lost on the night of the Johnstown Flood,
on the night of the Johnstown Flood.
Two thousand two hundred nine,
two thousand two hundred nine lives,
that was the price that was paid
on the night, on the night of the Johnstown Flood,
on the night of the Johnstown Flood.
The text
- Words by: Isaac G. Reed
- Year: 1889 (written in the months after the flood; the earliest printing found is 1890)
- Source edition: John J. McLaurin, The Story of Johnstown (Harrisburg: J. M. Place, 1890), where it appears untitled, introduced as "Isaac G. Reed has written." The National Park Service quotes its first stanza on a wayside sign at the Johnstown Flood National Memorial.
- Status: public domain (published 1890).
Changes to the text
- The song uses the poem's first stanza.
- It repeats "Worse than Herod's awful crime" as a chorus.
- It ends Reed's punchline ("Such was the price that was paid for... fish!") with new lines: "For the rich!" and the 2,209 refrain.